Decision 1
Estimate monthly gross sales first
A percentage fee is attractive at zero revenue and can become expensive as sales grow. A fixed subscription has the opposite shape.
Digital commerce comparison
Sellfy vs Gumroad: fixed subscription or percentage-of-sales economics
Sellfy charges a recurring subscription and advertises 0% Sellfy transaction fees on its paid plans. Gumroad has no monthly platform fee but charges a percentage plus a fixed amount on direct sales. Your revenue level changes the answer.
Planning range$0 fixed plus per-sale fees, or $39-$159+ monthly for Sellfy tiersUse this for architecture planning, not as a vendor quote. Verify current pricing before purchase.
Affiliate disclosure: We earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. That does not change what the Website Stack Engine recommends.
Decision framework
Make the choice in this order
Decision 2
Decide whether storefront ownership matters
If the brand needs a more dedicated storefront, marketing features and predictable platform cost, a fixed-fee store can be easier to plan.
Decision 3
Include payment processing and tax handling
Platform fees are not the whole transaction cost. Compare payment processing, merchant-of-record responsibilities and any marketplace fees separately.
Data-driven matrix
Compare the tools against the job
These rows come from the shared tool data layer. Affiliate status changes the outbound link, never the fit data or ordering logic.
| Tool | Planning cost | Setup | Digital products | Transaction model | Best for | Next step | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sellfy Creator-focused storefront for digital and simple product sales. | $$ | Very easy | Excellent | 0% platform transaction fee on paid plans checked | Built in | digital downloads, creator stores, small catalogs | Check Sellfy |
| Gumroad No-monthly-fee creator commerce platform that charges transaction-based platform fees on sales. | $0 fixed + transaction fees | Very easy | Excellent | Percentage fee per sale | Basic | testing digital products, low-volume creator sales, sellers prioritizing zero fixed platform cost | Visit Gumroad |
Do not buy this if
Software should remove a constraint.
- Do not choose Gumroad solely because the monthly fee is zero if percentage fees will dominate at your expected sales volume.
- Do not pay for Sellfy before you have products ready to sell and a reason to need its storefront features.
- Do not compare only base fees while ignoring payment processing.
- Do not assume the platform with more features is better for validating a first product.
Evidence checked
Pricing and product terms can change. These are the primary sources checked for this decision page.
FAQ
Questions that change the decision
Which is cheaper, Sellfy or Gumroad?
At low or zero sales, Gumroad has the lower fixed cost because there is no monthly platform charge. As direct sales increase, its percentage fee can make a fixed-fee Sellfy plan more predictable.
Does Sellfy charge transaction fees?
Sellfy states 0% Sellfy transaction fees on its paid plans; payment processors still charge their own fees.
What does Gumroad charge?
At our check, Gumroad listed 10% + $0.50 for direct/profile sales before card processing, with a different higher fee for marketplace discovery sales.